Skip to main contentSkip to primary navigationSkip to secondary navigation
bn.com
Holiday Gift Guide. Shop Now.
  • Books
  • Textbooks
  • eBooks
  • nook
  • Kids
  • Toys & Games
  • Movies & TV
  • Music
  • Home & Gift
  • Gift Cards
  • More

Melissa_W's Reviews & Ratings

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
  • List price: $14.95
    Online price: $11.96
    Member price: $10.76
    (Save 28%)
    Limited Time Offer! Everyone receives the Member Price on books.
    See Details
skip to cart

Weir is not a Richard III "revisionist"

Melissa_W's Reader Rating: See Detailed Ratings

This book has a different tone than the other Weir histories/biographies I've read recently. She's not rehabilitating a historical figure or detailing the causes of a civil war; this time she's showing us the extant historical record and whether or not that historical record tells us what happened to Edward V and his brother, Richard. The story of the Princes doesn't flow quite like her other books because she has to back up a few times to go over the origins of historical documents and the accuracy of contemprorary sources (Sir Thomas More's biography of Richard III is considered a particularly accurate source because More had access to those close to Richard during his reign). In the end, Weir's interpretation of the historical evidence makes it clear that Richard III is implicated in the deaths of the Princes and that the children died before Henry VII invaded England. Whether Richard III ordered the childen's murder or they died through natural causes or mistreatment is unclear but it was widely believed that the Princes were dead by 1485 because Richard was unable to exhibit the children in public when it would have been politically advantageous to do so. If you are a Richard III revisionist, this book is not for you. If you like Shakespeare's play then you'll like this book because it gives dimension and context to one of Shakespeare's famous villains.

I also recommend:

Why do you want to flag this review?

Plot Spoiler

Inappropriate or abusive language

Off-topic content

Spam, private or commercial solicitation

Suspected underage user

Terms of Use Violation

Suspected copyright infringement

Reviews and Ratings

Sort By:

1 - 25 Next
The Children's BookA. S. Byatt
Another beautiful novel from Byatt
Bloom County Complete Library, Volume 1Berkeley Breathed
Bloom County is the best!
Ophelia Joined the Group Maidens Who Don't FloatSarah Schmelling
Perfect for the FB-addicted bibliophile
Under This Unbroken SkyShandi Mitchell
Heartbreaking and honest
Shelf DiscoveryLizzie Skurnick
A must-have for anyone who loves YA literature
The White TigerAravind Adiga
Unusual, thought-provoking
Death Comes for the ArchbishopWilla Cather
If you like "My Antonia" or "O Pioneers" you should read this one, too
Henry VIIIAlison Weir
Very detail-oriented, but accessible
Burn This BookToni Morrison
Support PEN!
Water GhostsShawna Yang Ryan
Ethereal and unique
A Canticle for LeibowitzWalter M. Miller
Thought-provoking and entertaining
The Story of a MarriageAndrew Sean Greer
Beautiful writing, Pearlie is a wonderful narrator
The Princes in the TowerAlison Weir
Weir is not a Richard III "revisionist"
The Amazing Adventures of DietgirlShauna Reid
An uplifting, endearing journey
Emma (Barnes & Noble Classics Series)Jane Austen
Austen's hard-to-love heroine does good
The Wars of the RosesAlison Weir
If you need a thorough overview, this is it
The Physick Book of Deliverance DaneKatherine Howe
Good for summer reading
The Beach Street Knitting Society and Yarn ClubGil McNeil
A fun read, perfect for the beach this summer
Queen IsabellaAlison Weir
She-wolf to diplomat
DroodDan Simmons
It keeps you turning the pages!
The Well and the MineGin Phillips
Haunting, well-crafted
Mistress of the MonarchyAlison Weir
Amazing research, attempts to separate fiction from history
This Republic of SufferingDrew Gilpin Faust
Well-written and plenty of information
Travels with HerodotusRyszard Kapuscinski
Ancient and modern history intersect using Herodotus
Searching for Jane AustenEmily Auerbach
Engaging Literary Analysis
1 - 25 Next